An inconvenient Peace Prize

Posted on: Monday, October 15th, 2007 by Renaissance Men

THIS YEAR'S Nobel Peace Prize justly rewards the thousands of scientists of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. These scientists are engaged in excellent, painstaking work that establishes exactly what the world should expect from climate change.

The other award winner, former US vice president Al Gore, has spent much more time telling us what to fear. While the IPCC's estimates and conclusions are grounded in careful study, Gore doesn't seem to be similarly restrained.

Gore told the world in his Academy Award-winning movie to expect 20-foot sea-level rises over this century. He ignores the findings of his Nobel co-winners, who conclude that sea levels will rise between only a half-foot and two feet over this century, with their best expectation being about one foot. That's similar to what the world experienced over the past 150 years.

Likewise, Gore agonizes over the accelerated melting of ice in Greenland and what it means for the planet, but overlooks the IPCC's conclusion that, if sustained, the current rate of melting would add just 3 inches to the sea-level rise by the end of the century. Gore also takes no notice of research showing that Greenland's temperatures were higher in 1941 than they are today.

The politician-turned-moviemaker loses sleep over a predicted rise in heat-related deaths. There's another side of the story that's inconvenient to mention: rising temperatures will reduce the number of cold spells, which are a much bigger killer than heat. The best study shows that by 2050, heat will claim 400,000 more lives, but 1.8 million fewer will die because of cold. Indeed, according to the first complete survey of the economic effects of climate change for the world, global warming will actually save lives.

Gore has helped the world to worry. Unfortunately, our attention is diverted from where it matters. Climate change is not the only problem facing the globe.

Gore concentrates on his call for world leaders to cut CO2 emissions, yet there are other policies that would do much more for the planet. Over the coming century, developing nations will be increasingly dependent on food imports from developed countries. This is not primarily a result of global warming, but a consequence of more people and less arable land in the developing world.

The number of hungry people depends much less on climate than on demographics and income. Extremely expensive cuts in carbon emissions could mean more malnourished people. If our goal is to fight malnutrition, policies like getting nutrients to those who need them are 5,000 times more effective at saving lives than spending billions of dollars cutting carbon emissions.

Likewise, global warming will probably slightly increase malaria, but CO2 reductions will be far less effective at fighting this disease than mosquito nets and medication, which can cheaply save 850,000 lives every year. By contrast, the expensive Kyoto Protocol will prevent just 1,400 deaths from malaria each year.

While we worry about the far-off effects of climate change, we do nothing to deal with issues facing the planet today. This year, malnutrition will kill almost 4 million people. About 3 million lives will be lost to HIV/AIDS, and 2 1/2 million people will die because of indoor and outdoor air pollution. A lack of micronutrients and clean drinking water will claim 2 million lives each.

With attention and money in scarce supply, we should first tackle the problems with the best solutions, doing the most good throughout the century. If we focus on solving today's problems, we will leave communities strengthened, economies more vibrant, and infrastructures more robust. This will enable these societies to deal much better with future problems - including global warming. Committing to massive cuts in carbon emissions will leave future generations poorer and less able to adapt to challenges.

Gore has an unshakable faith that climate change is the world's biggest challenge. To be fair, he deserves some recognition for his resolute passion. However, the contrast between the Nobel winners could not be sharper. The IPCC engages in meticulous research where facts rule over everything else. Gore has a different approach.

Bjorn Lomborg is adjunct professor at the Copenhagen Business School, and author of "Cool It" and "The Skeptical Environmentalist."

© Copyright 2007 Globe Newspaper Company.

---

Articles by Renaissance Men

Title	Published
Open ANWAR Already! By Jon Basil Utley	09-30-08
Lloyd Marcus Writes Song for Sarah Palin . . . Lyrics below	09-08-08
The Tyranny of the Atheist Minority	05-20-08
VICTORIOUS PESSIMISM, Observation of Democrat Debates	01-23-08
An inconvenient Peace Prize	10-15-07
Wanted: Conservative savior	11-12-06
Youre a Republican???	10-20-04
An Edwards Outrage	10-20-04
Revenge is a Dish Best Served Cold	10-12-04
I'm headed downstairs to check my Heinz labels.	10-12-04
Kerry Smeared A Hero: My Dad	10-12-04
AMERICAN NOBILITY	08-30-04
Rock and Roll Hall of Shame	08-06-04
REAL Vietnam Heroes Blast Kerry's Lies	06-30-04
Lech Walesa Credits Reagan With Poland's Freedom	06-13-04
Pat Boone Accusses CBS of Being Modern Benedict Arnold	06-02-04
Pro-life Women Are in the Majority	04-25-04
What Renaissance Men in the Military are Saying About Kerry	02-17-04
Open Letter to John Kerry from a Real Vietnam Hero	02-16-04
Watch this and Realize How Important it is to Vote in November.	02-09-04
Response to Nina's Commentary by Vietnam Vet	02-02-04
YOU DON’T HAVE TO WIN TO WIN	01-30-04
Watch this and Realize How Important it is to Vote in November. All George Soros money could not seem to buy an entire brain within the democrat/socialist party.	01-28-04
Bolting for Bush---- Edward I. Koch Sunday, Jan. 11, 2004	01-27-04
The Politics Of Secrecy	01-01-04
George Bush vs. the Naive Nine	11-20-03
Crucifixion	10-21-03
Public Statement of the Schindler Family in Response to the Statement of Michael Schia	10-20-03
MOVIE COMPANIES TRY TO MANIPULATE THE CHURCH	09-23-03
Wesley Clark in living color	09-22-03
Enemies Within Think of Them Every Day	09-16-03
Outside View: Catholics need not apply	09-08-03
THE FINAL STAND	08-25-03
What Will George Bush Do About North Korea? How to win without really trying.	08-01-03
GIVING CREDIT WHERE IT IS DUE	07-07-03
Busting the "Old Homeboys" Network...Europe invades the NBA	07-01-03
Very Honest Commencement Address Rarely Heard on College Campuses	06-30-03
Homeschoolers in the trenches	06-18-03
SEIZING THE MOMENT	05-30-03
Is China Our Biggest Threat to Democracy?	05-24-03
The threat among us	05-20-03
Setting the Record Straight for Senator "Double Standards" Byrd	05-13-03
North Korea: Blind Spots of Crimes Against Humanity	04-30-03
Quran (9:11)	04-29-03
NO SPECIAL STATUS	04-23-03
Our Soldiers	04-12-03
Letter from US Navy Pilot to the Dixie Chickens	03-15-03
The Coming Arab Rennaissance? In their own words:
Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Debate Made Public Opinion More Pro-Life
"Wish You Were Here"
A Seabee’s First Hand Account of Life in Iraq
The Illogic of Immoral Public Policy
Self-Destructive Support
Better Late Than Never

Previous Page :: Main Page

Categories

---

---

Renaissance Women

---

Profiles, images and commentaries written by the following spokeswomen:

---

Join Our Mailing List

Receive Newsletters, Special Offers, and Regular Bulletins from Renaissance Women

---